There were 59 quarterbacks in 2024 who started at least one game during the 2024 season. So, where did the Indianapolis Colts’ Anthony Richardson rank among that group?
Nick Shook of NFL.com recently ranked all 59 of those quarterbacks and Richardson came in at No. 35 on his list.
“Overall, Richardson isn’t nearly consistent enough to make most believe he’s the answer for the Colts — yet, “wrote Shook. “He’s not at the stage most expected him to be at after two years, and Year 3 is going to be pivotal. But if he figures it out, watch out.”
A few spots ahead of Richardson was Jameis Winston at No. 32, followed by Will Levis and Tyler Huntley. Just behind Richardson was Gardner Minshew at No. 36, followed by Daniel Jones, and Cooper Rush.
Colts’ backup quarterback Joe Flacco was No. 40 in Shook’s rankings.
In 11 games last season, Richardson completed just 48% of his passes at 6.9 yards per pass attempt with eight interceptions and 12 touchdowns, according to PFF.
Compared to the rest of his position group, Richardson ranked 44th in completion rate out of 44 eligible quarterbacks. He was tied for 23rd in yards per pass attempt, and had the fifth-highest turnover-worthy play rate.
Richardson’s season was defined by inconsistency. The inability to connect regularly on the short to intermediate passes led to struggles sustaining drives, short possessions for the Colts offense, and a lack of points.
For that reason, along with Richardson needing to show that he can stay healthy for a full season, GM Chris Ballard did say there will be competition for Richardson this summer.
The Colts are not giving up on Richardson, but they need improved play from him.
Some positives to hold on to going into 2025 are that Richardson’s play did improve once he returned from being benched. Not only were his numbers better, but from an operation standpoint, such as his command and playing within the timing and rhythm of the play did improve–not to mention that Shane Steichen utilized Richardson in the run game more.
In addition to that, unlike last offseason, Richardson is fully healthy this time around, giving him a head start compared to where he was a season ago. Richardson will also be working with the same quarterback coach who helped Josh Allen early in his career.